The exact identity of this young boy has never been established, but the suggestion that he is a child of the Cottenet family seems valid in terms of his dates, the artist and the provenance. Although from a Charleston family, he spent most of his childhood in New York where Carlin might have painted him.
Notes:
This text is adapted from Martha Severens "The Miniature Portrait Collection of the Carolina Art Association" published by the Carolina Art Association, 1984